Penny Lane Is Dead (2026) Review

Some horror films want to unsettle you, and some want to hand you a weapon. Penny Lane Is Dead is the second kind. It’s a bloody, punk-fueled revenge movie from Australia, and the reviews suggest it knows exactly which buttons it’s pressing, even when it presses a few too hard.

The setup

The film is the debut feature of special effects, hair and makeup artist Mia’Kate Russell, who fuses punk rock with sunburnt Aussie horror. It’s set in summer 1986, with school out, and Screenhub calls it a raucous riot grrrl punk horror. The cast includes Tahlee Fereday, Sophia Wright-Mendelsohn and Ben O’Toole.

The structure is deliberately old-school. One critic describes a classic home invasion setup that leads into another grindhouse staple, the rape/revenge thriller. Roger Ebert’s site notes the antagonists are bad news, clearly willing to kill far more than the vibes before the film escalates quickly into a bad-time B-movie bloodfest.

If you know the genre, you know the template. The question is what the film does with it.

Ozploitation, revived

Reviewers keep returning to the same label. JoBlo says the film is keeping the tradition alive, giving us an 80s movie with the same Ozploitation vibes. Ozploitation is the loud, sweaty, low-budget Australian genre cinema of the ’70s and ’80s, and its appeal is rough edges and a willingness to go too far.

That’s both the pitch and the problem, as Moviejawn’s headline puts it: it’s a fun throwback to Ozploitation’s heyday, but lacks its grit. The film borrows the style, the soundtrack and the attitude, but some critics feel it’s a little too polished and knowing to match the dangerous feel of the originals. Whether that bothers you depends on whether you want a homage or a re-creation.

Where it hits hardest: the effects

Russell’s background in effects shows. JoBlo gives the film an 8 out of 10 and says the violence is where it really shines, filled with bloody practical effects that it knows how to show off. A first-time director who has spent a career building this stuff has an obvious edge, and horror fans who still prefer prosthetics and blood to CGI should be happy.

The tone: funny and cruel at once

The most interesting claim in the reviews is about tone. The Movie Waffler calls it a small miracle in how it seamlessly blends exploitative violence with rib-tickling comedy. The Guardian’s headline captures the shift: it zips from Neighbours to nasty, a nod to the sunny Australian suburban soap and how abruptly the film turns dark. Punchdrunk Critics goes further, calling it brutal, nasty, hilarious female-rage revenge. One reviewer also notes that the film is a revenge movie on two fronts, which suggests the story is aiming at something beyond its plot, though I can’t speak to how well it lands.

Mixing humor with this subject matter is a high-wire act. It works for the reviewers who feel the film earns its catharsis, and it’s the main reason others pull back.

Where it divides

The split among critics is real. Rue Morgue says it’s very far from a bad film, with some good, rousingly nasty moments, but the positives are too few and far between, and it ultimately fails to deliver on its promises. It adds that the film’s attempts to combine its two modes work with varying results. A Shudder-adjacent reviewer says they thought they were going to love it, and the framing of that review suggests it didn’t fully get there.

ScreenAnarchy is the most useful for deciding whether this is for you. That reviewer came away appreciating the craft but found it at times an endurance trial of cruelty, and noted that won’t be everyone’s takeaway. Even the fans acknowledge the harshness. One writer says festival audiences had strong feelings about its mean streak, which is sustained throughout a fleet 85-minute runtime.

That short runtime helps. A film this relentless would be exhausting at two hours, and 85 minutes keeps it lean. Even so, the cruelty in the first act is the price of admission, and it is a steep one.

The verdict

Taken together, the coverage points to a film that is more than a shock vehicle, with real craft, a strong point of view and a lot of personality. It also leaves some viewers cold, either because it doesn’t match the grit of the genre it’s honoring or because its cruelty is hard to enjoy. Film Carnage is blunt about the upside: for slasher and B-movie fans, is it worth watching? An emphatic yes.

My read, from the reporting: this looks like an assured, gleefully mean debut that’s best enjoyed knowing exactly what you’re signing up for. It’s strongest as a practical-effects showcase and a cathartic revenge story, and weakest if you want the true grime of the 1980s originals.

Watch it if: you love grindhouse revenge films, practical gore, and horror with a punk attitude and a dark sense of humor.

Skip it if: sexual violence is a hard line for you, or if you want your throwbacks rougher and less polished.

RATING: 3/5

You can watch on: 

Trailer:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *